Search Helium

Home > Celebrations & Holidays > Gifts & Gift Ideas > Gift Advice

Is it impolite to sell something you received as a gift?

Results so far:

Yes
50% 526 votes Total: 1054 votes
No
50% 528 votes

Yes

by Pati Baur

Created on: March 22, 2009   Last Updated: March 23, 2009

I am proud to say, that although I have received many odd and strange gifts I have never been able to sell them. The number one reason for that is, that I believe that the person giving me this gift has done so because they really believed that I would like it or need it. So I have managed to hang on to some odd vases and pictures and clothes that make me break out when I wear them.

Some of the pieces I have even displayed at my house and they have turned out to be great conversation pieces! But when spring cleaning comes, somehow and don't ask me how, they seem to disappear and be given away. I cannot hold on to them forever. The only exception would be some pieces given to me by my family or friends. I have to honor them forever no matter what. They survive the spring cleaning somehow.

In my view it would be totally impolite to do this or maybe I am just a big chicken and don't want a 3 hour confrontation about why their lovely gifts are not there anymore.

Nevertheless, I think it is bad manners to sell a gift. I want to advise people to try to find some use and maybe donate it instead of selling it. That is the more polite way to go.

Now that we are on this topic , I wonder how many of my gifts have ever been sold. I feel panic mode coming over me. I always thought as myself as the perfect gift giver and now that bubble might have been popped. Maybe, we can all learn from this? I'm starting to think that I should probably really think twice before giving a gift from now on. The idea that it could be sold at some garage sale is killing me.

So, for all of you out there who think it is totally acceptable to sell gifts, well it is not. Do you see my pain? Please try to resist the temptation to sell the gift and instead display it in a prominent place for a year and see what people say about it.

To be honest the biggest gripe for me is why sell it? That is the part that caught my eye. Sell you say! No, so very impolite. How would you explain it to the person who gave it to you? Lie? So sell and lie? Oh that is so sad. How can you sleep at night? I seem to be coming down hard on all the people who think this is fine to do..I am sorry..but please stop doing it. I for one will be grateful that you don't do it. Especially if you do not need the money and are just trying to make a profit out of someones gift to you. I hope this has helped you either way. It is always better to be polite than impolite in my eyes.

Learn more about this author, Pati Baur.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Lorelei Cohen

Created on: March 17, 2008

Gifts come in many forms and are given for many different reasons. Although sometimes gifts are given with an ulterior motive in mind, generally gifts are given with the sole intention of increasing the wellbeing or happiness of the receiver, and as such are given without a need for reciprocation.

Sometimes a gift is the giving of one's service to another. Gifts given to uplift the spirits of another person or creature can be as simple as the giving of a kiss or a hug. Other gifts of this nature might include watching a neighbors home while they are away, mowing an elderly persons lawn, housecleaning, babysitting, accounting services, a haircut or a manicure, and each of these gifts would be given strictly for the immediate benefit that they provide to the receiver.

Generally though, when we think of gift giving, we picture the present itself as a much more tangible object that is presented to the receiver. These gifts are however still often given to alleviate the stresses of, or to increase the happiness of the recipient, and may include packages of food or clothing, gift certificates or money.

Luxury items such as artwork, jewelry, antiques or collectibles may also be given as gifts, and besides being cherished for their sentimental value, these items may come with the added benefit of a potential increase to their original value the older they become. These luxury items are of course usually given to enhance the pleasure of the person who receives them, but over the course of time, that pleasure may be more aptly received through the monies that the sale of these same articles can provide. As true gift giving is done without obligation on the part of the beneficiary, the choice as to whether or not to take advantage in the selling of the original gift is one that is solely to be decided upon by the recipient of that gift. How they can derive the greatest pleasure from the gift, is something that only they may know, so it is at their discretion to choose as to how the gift will best serve their needs. The gift after all is theirs. As previously defined, a gift is given without obligation, and as such it should no longer have any connection to the giver once it is given.

So if grandma's diamond earrings bring you more pleasure as food on the table, than they currently are sitting in your jewelry box, by all means visit your local antique dealer to see what price they may be able to fetch. If selling that gosh awful statue that sits in your closet because it is just too ugly to decorate your living room, pop a picture of it on E-bay, if Uncle Henry truly cares about you then he'll understand. If he doesn't, then maybe the next time he selects a gift for someone, he'll think a little more carefully and truly choose a gift for their enjoyment instead of his own.

So go ahead, and enjoy your gift, as you see it fits you best.

Learn more about this author, Lorelei Cohen.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA