Home > Parenting & Pregnancy > Parenting Styles > Parenting Styles (Other)
Results so far:
| Yes | 33% | 277 votes | Total: 840 votes | |
| No | 67% | 563 votes |
Yes
Created on: May 23, 2009
Will you copy your parents' parenting style? There are two answers to this question. Both are blatantly correct in their own wisdom. The answers are so conclusive that the raising of the question seems superfluous. The first answer is 'of course yes'. The second is 'of course no'.
Psychologists can spend a great deal of time debating the intricacies of behaviourism. They can label different thoughts with different names and even devote many different subjects to the same thought. It all comes back to a simple notion. When an organism, just like a human, experiences an occurrence, a feeling or a stimulus that reinforces the experience, it is likely that the organism will want to experience that activity again. If the stimulus has a negative effect, it is unlikely that the organism will go out of its way to experience similar angst.
Except for genetically pre programmed instinct, when you are born you have an empty database in relation to how you should parent when you have evolved as a human. It makes sense then that you will have to observe and model how you will parent based on the experiences that you travel through on life's journey. It is quite difficult to conceptualise just how many parenting experiences that there have been and will be during our reign. Infinite is a good word to describe this number but not quite correct, so it can be deduced that it is inconceivable to be able collate information from every parenting event and come up with the golden handbook for parenting. I believe that nearly anyone who is responsibly contemplating becoming a parent will be filled with vibrations of trepidation and would love such a magic little handbook.
Without a blueprint, there is only one option for the budding parent. Observe and feel and learn from every parenting experience that passes by. If it is a positive observation or feeling or lesson, you will file it away in the how I should be a good parent binder of your soul. A negative response will be thrown on top of the I am confused because I didn't like what happened but if someone else did it, it may be possible that it is correct pile. This pile is not a very helpful pile of information because it is disorganised and unfortunately you will be continually referring back to it, throwing pieces of information around the room looking for that snippet that may help you out in a particular situation. Overall, you will carry all the positive observations into your parenting role, which in many situations may just be quite similar to the role that your parent played.
Not only will you observe your own parents in action. You will also study every other parent that you encounter along the way. If you like what you see you will probably add it to your repertoire of 'how to parent skills'. Now comes the twist! Not every person experiences life similarly. What might be reinforcing for you may be distasteful for another. Ahh, the human condition.
Inevitably, you will parent in your own unique style. You will continue to question every parenting action that you take, fearing that it may be deleterious for your loved one. It is wasted worry because your progeny is watching every action also and compiling their personal unique filing system. If you are parenting by instinct, driven to continue your line, it will work out ok. It always has.
Learn more about this author, Mark Mahon.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
Created on: August 31, 2009
A better question to ask potential parents considering copying their parents parenting style is Why? One of the traits that differentiates humans from animals is our ability to quickly adapt to changing conditions. If one is intending to raise their children just as their parents raised them, in order to have a remote chance of success, you'd have to turn back the hands of time. For my kids, I would have to let them watch only black and white TV, ride bicycles to get anywhere, only let them go to G-rated movies and ensure they have no contact with any other kids who could potentially "corrupt" them.
Rapidly changing lifestyles and technologies make this impossible to do. The only folks I can think who have a chance at this, are those who live in religious run communes or commuities like Luddites or Amish or even Mormons. Even for these folks they have to shun technology and carefully control who their kids interact with. Unfortunately sooner or later the kids end up making contact with the rest of the world then watch out. I haven't seen any statistics but am willing to bet many young folks take off for greener pastures or look for chances to sample the "forbidden fruits" of technology and current media.
In addition to a radically different lifestyle, the next question is which parents' parenting style is a couple going to follow? For example there were some things my in-laws did that I agree with when raising my spouse and her siblings that my parents didn't do and there are somethings my parents did when raising my and my siblings that my in-laws didn't do. Trying to follow one parenting style or the other is bound to cause ill fillings between the potential parents. So it adds friction to a marriage.
Finally the third and most fatal problem with trying to copy your parents parenting style is adaptability. In other words there are some conditions that potential parents will need to deal with that their parents didn't have to worry about. For example, if my son wanted to pierce his ear to wear earrings, do we let him do it? I know for a fact that neither myself or my other brothers ever asked my parents for permission to do this. Likewise, my brother in laws didn't ask my in-laws for permission to do this either. So what does one do? Most of the time, call one or both sets of parents and ask them for guidance on what to say. The odds are, the two sets of parents will give contradictory advice, then what? Flip a coin? Argue all night with your spouse?
In my humble opinion, the best any potential parent can do is to decide on their own. Maybe you're right and maybe you're wrong. Only time will tell. Good luck and for goodness sake, don't waste your time trying to copy your parents' parenting style.
Learn more about this author, R Shimoda.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.