Search Helium

Home > Jobs & Careers > Managing Your Career > Getting Ahead

Will higher education or work experience get you ahead faster in your career?

Results so far:

Education
42% 453 votes Total: 1066 votes
Experience
58% 613 votes

Education

by Barry Marcus

Created on: January 17, 2008   Last Updated: July 09, 2009

Higher education is a key to success both within and outside of the corporate world. Some qualifications are highly sought after and rewarded. A professional degree is particularly valuable. An accounting degree leading to the professional chartered accountant qualification is particularly valuable. An MBA degree has been known to propel individuals from middle management to executive level in record time.

Work experience can and does move a career forward. There are times when that experience is highly recognised. At times an academic institution will award a degree for work experience.

We have all heard about the office-boy that makes it to CEO, but this is the exception that proves the rule. Career success without education is a diminishing phenomenon. Appropriate qualifications are gaining in importance as each year passes. There will always be the exception of the highly dynamic individual that succeeds without a higher education. There will always be the entrepreneurial types that do not rely on education and there is always a chance of succeeding in business through sheer ability.

For most people, education is a necessity to advance a career. A bachelor's degree, master's degree or MBA have become prerequisites for a range of jobs or occupations. A hundred years of working in the medical field is not enough to make you a doctor.

Stuart worked his way up the corporate ladder to a position of Assistant General Manager over the course of twenty years. Once the company showed signs of being in trouble he was one of the first to be retrenched. Armed with only a school leaving certificate he struggled to find alternative employment.

By contrast, an actuarial student entered the same business and even before completing the qualification began a rapid career rise. Within a year of qualifying, he was a general manager.

A qualification in itself is no guarantee of career success. The corporate world is a very political place and you need to be a political player to climb the ladder. Other factors are at play. Performance on the job is crucial. But as a rule, those that are able to use their education effectively in the work environment are more successful than those that simply rely on work experience.

The value of education as a key to success is sharply evident when we look at the various professions. Entrance to a whole range of professions including accountancy, law, medicine, engineering or actuarial science is limited to those with appropriate education. A newly qualified chartered accountant can earn double the national average salary within two years of qualifying. Actuaries are amongst the highest earners in the world.

Perhaps the most important consideration is in the transferability of the skills. Twenty years experience and climbing the corporate ladder in one company does not make it easy to obtain another job. A professional qualification, on the other hand is a far greater help.

Learn more about this author, Barry Marcus.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Experience

by Nick Bianco

Created on: January 21, 2009

Experience will win over education every time. Work experience will provide an education in itself, while even the best education will never amount to one day of experience. Granted there are some careers where it is impossible to gain experience without first having education, such as a surgeon or a lawyer. But for the vast majority of jobs, there is no substitute for experience.

A classroom education is certainly a good thing to have, but in the real world, many of the problems and situations that arise can only be dealy with effectively by a person with experience. Textbooks and professors can provide you with the basics, but even the best education in the world cannot possibly cover every scenario that arises in the real world.

As an owner of a small business, I would feel much more comfortable hiring an individual who had worked in the field for 4 years, than someone who has a 4-year college education but has never held a job. When you work in a certain field, you recieve an invaluable hands-on education, the likes of which cannot be purchased with tuition or a diploma.

Ideally, the best way to get ahead in a career is by having a combination of both education and work experience. Those who are well-educated will surely know a few things that the average worker doesn't, and an experienced worker will surely know things that a well-educated neophyte does not. A savvy employer will hire both types of people, knowing that the experienced employees can help develop those just out of college, and the well-educated employees can teach a few things to the seasoned employees. By combining both types of employees, the well-experienced and the well-educated, you are maximizing every employee's potential.

Building a sucessful business team is no different than building a championship sports team. In sports, teams that win championships have a balanced mix of veteran players and rookies, stars and utility players. A team comprised only of talented rookies will never win a championship; likewise, a business which employs only workers with a high level of education will never reach its full potential. Similarly, a team that only has veteran players will never win a championship. However, if it were strictly a case of one versus the other, a team with highly-experienced players will always perform better than a team of players lacking in experience.

Even the most experienced employee can rise to new heights in their career by continuing their education. A well-educated employee can only climb the ladder of success through experience. So while both experience and education are essential to success, those who already have several years of work experience will be able to get ahead in their career faster.

Learn more about this author, Nick Bianco.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA