Football

Does the New York Giants' Super Bowl appearance enable Eli Manning out of Peyton's shadow?

Results so far:

No		37%	41 votes	Total: 112 votes
Yes		63%	71 votes	Total: 112 votes

1 of 3
by Rolando Cruz

Peyton Manning casts a tall shadow. A shadow that stretches far beyond his athletic achievements on the football field and jumps into your living room by way of his latest TV co...read more
2 of 3
by Ashley Evans

The entertaining Manning boys. No, I don't think Eli will ever get out of the shadow of Peyton. This is really the first year he has taken the Giants to the playoffs and became ...read more
3 of 3
by Nicole Williams

I don't think it would matter if the Giants went to the Super Bowl and won. Unfortunately, I think Eli will always be in Peyton's shadow. Peyton Manning has been an NFL quarterb...read more

Join the Debate now.
Write your point of view.

1 of 7
by Michael Podlesny

There is no question he is no longer in the shadow of Peyton. In fact regardless of regular season stats Eli was able to do what Peyton did not do in the Superbowl and that was...read more
2 of 7
by Cody Hodge

Oh yes, Eli Manning is out of his brothers shadow after his appearance in the Super Bowl. It wasn't so much that he made the Super Bowl, as many lesser quarterbacks have played ...read more
3 of 7
by Mighty-Pen

Does the New York Giants' Super Bowl appearance enable Eli Manning out of Peyton's shadow? The National Football League is rather unique than most professional sports. The ...read more
4 of 7
by Stuart Appley

Yes. These last 12 wins have gotten Eli Manning out of his brothers shadows. Going into the playoffs everyone was impressed at how the Giants had won 10 games in a row, but nobo...read more
5 of 7
by Bryan Hooyman

In my mind not only is Eli out of his brother's [Peyton] Shadow now, but I'd have to that say he has surpassed Peyton and is casting a shadow of his own on his older brother now...read more
6 of 7
by Marcus Brooks

Ever since his controversial 2004 Draft Night, Giants' quarterback, Eli Manning succumbed inside Peyton Manning's shadow. He looked up to 49 touchdowns, two MVPs, multiple 4,00...read more
7 of 7

by Patricia Farley

Yes the New York Giants' Super Bowl appearance to enable Eli Manning out of his brother Peyton's shadow. There is much talk about Peyton being a football superstar, but little t...read more

Football: Do former NFL players make the best football commentators?; Does New York Giants' coach Tom Coughlin's job depend on another playoff win?; Which NFL legacy is more impressive: New England Patriots ( 2000s) vs. San Fransisco 49ers (1980s)?; Should more New York Giants have been Pro Bowl selections?; Who gets the best pass interference calls, defense or offense?

Helium, Inc.

200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA