Home > Politics, News & Issues > Sports News & Opinion > Football News & Opinion
Results so far:
| Yes | 60% | 100 votes | Total: 166 votes | |
| No | 40% | 66 votes |
Yes
Created on: January 10, 2008 Last Updated: October 31, 2008
There are many cases easily made on why the New England Patriots are an NFL dynasty: 3 Super Bowls in 4 years, undefeated regular season, future Hall of Famer head coach and quarter back. While these are universal givens, here are some reasons why the Patriots are a dynasty in spite of any arguments against.
1) Winning in the free agency and salary cap era. While the NFL has pushed for parity, and by and large has acquired it (expansion teams Jacksonville AND Carolina in the conference championships in their second year), no team has successfully figured out how to string together an organization that can accomplish winning over the long haul. When GM Scott Pioli and head coach Bill Bilichek teamed up together in 2000, they devised a 4-year plan to get the Pats to be Super Bowl Champs. They not only did that in 2003 (and 2004), but also snuck one in during 2001.
2) They devised a system that promotes team work, football fundamentals, winning, and unselfishness. Are all of the Patriots well-behaved saints? Certainly not. However, all the players and coaches are all about the business at hand, staying extremely focused, and not making a media circus of the organization, like so many other players and teams do. They have a job to do, and that is only to win the next scheduled game. No Super Bowl Shuffle. No distractions. No pomp and circumstance. Just do our job, and that is win.
3) They win in spite of a stacked schedule in the NFL against strong teams. The schedule is devised as such: win this year, get penalized with the toughest schedule next year. This is established to foster competition and level the playing field. But they still make the playoffs, and win, each year.
4) For the last 6 years, they have had a huge target on their backs. Multiple championships, always beating the Colts, and having pathetic coaches cry "Cheaters" (which all teams do, the NFL just made an example of the Pats - as many former NFL players have testified on TV this year) have branded this team as Public Enemy #1. Whether your a playoff-caliber team or a floundering franchise, if you beat the Pats, you've made your season. While every body has gunned for them since 2001, they keep pushing the bar further. If you're gonna win, you better bring your "A" game, and some luck.
5) Doing more with less. Previous dynasties have won with many great Hall of Famers, and while the Pats have a few to be sure, they do not have the roster depth that, say, the Steelers or the Niners had. Deion Branch? Not very effective in Seattle. Adam Vinateiri? Suddenly became human in Indy. Randy Moss? Resurrected his career in NE. Tom Brady? 199th six-round draft pick. Troy Brown? Most versatile and underrated player in NFL. New England can scout them, provides the system and environment, and turns them into winners. No other team can claim that.
The Patriots have proven this year that they can raise the bar. They have beaten losing and determined teams (Ravens, Eagles, NY Giants), as well as the best in the league (Colts, Steelers, Cowboys) this year. People want to prove them cheaters, want to disrupt their winning streak. But the New England Patriots have something that no one has seen since Lombardi's Packer dynasty of the 60's. They are determined to beat you. And if you by some chance beat them today, you will definitely lose tomorrow.
Learn more about this author, francios.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
Created on: January 07, 2008 Last Updated: October 31, 2008
The New England Patriots are not emerging as an NFL dynasty simply because such a thing does not exist. In the era of Free Agency and big money contracts, no team can maintain the number of talented players, coaches, and front office personnel necessary to ensure multiple championships. While the Patriots have had an historic season, it is important to examine all the factors which led to such dominance.
Firstly, the Patriots are blessed with a franchise quarterback who has proven over the years to be worthy of future enshrinement in the Hall of Fame. Only a handful of NFL teams have such stability and prosperity at this position, and all of them relish it mightily. While it is unlikely Tom Brady will ever leave New England or retire while still in his prime, there is always the fear of an injury, as a severe knee or arm malady would certainly spell any team's doom.
Also, this was an offseason in which the Patriots acted very un-Patriotlike in order to improve their roster. A team that has traditionally valued team loyalty and developing rookies rather than buying up big money stars; this past offseason the Patriots spent lavish sums of cash in order to bring Donte Stallworth, Adalius Thomas, Wes Welker, and Randy Moss into the lineup. While it has paid off in the short-term, as these stars' contracts expire, it is unlikely that New England will be able to pay them the type of money necessary to retain their services.
Finally, every great team sees a mass exodus of coaching and front office talent leave the year after they meet with great success. Other teams looking to fill head coaching, vice-president of football operations, and general manager vacancies tend to first look toward the team with the most success the previous season. Therefore, there is no reason not to suspect this same phenomenon will befall New England once the Lombardi Trophy has been handed to this year's Super Bowl champs.
The modern NFL strives for parity, and while a few teams constantly hover among the top of the standings, the league is structured in such a way that no team will ever be able to establish themselves as a dynasty. While the Patriots may very well be one of the best teams on the field right now, things will change, and soon we'll all be talking about the next flash in the pan that makes us all sit up and take notice... until the process repeats itself again.
Learn more about this author, Brad Hilderbrand.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.