Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Society & Lifestyle   >

Ethnicity & Gender (Other)

Would you move into a neighborhood if you were the only person of your race living there?

Results so far:

Yes
59% 396 votes Total: 672 votes
No
41% 276 votes
Yes

For most of my adult life, I have lived in neighborhoods where I was the only one of my race. I am Hispanic, female, well-educated, and my English is accent free. As an attorney in Dallas, Texas, I have been able to command impressive earnings and buy homes in what are otherwise all-white neighborhoods. I cannot remember a single instance when anyone in the neighborhood has come to introduce themselves to me or to welcome me. Sure, people would wave if I happened to drive by, or say hello if I walked past them on the sidewalk, but that was the extent of my interaction with them. By hiring a professional lawn service, I kept my yard beautifully groomed and landscaped; home repairs were performed promptly, and I never had loud or late parties. Still, the neighbors stayed away. Was it because I was single? Because I was childless? Because I am Hispanic? How could I know? That's not a question that will get you an honest answer from most people you ask.

About ten years ago I married a Hispanic man. His family background and upbringing are essentially like mine; we both had parents whose English and education was limited and we grew up poor. We lived in all-Hispanic neighborhoods called barrios, and our neighborhood schools were almost entirely Hispanic, although all the teachers were white, Anglo-Saxon, and presumably protestant. Although he did not finish high school, my husband eventually became an aircraft mechanic working for the aviation division of a large multinational corporation. His pay enabled him to buy a nice home in a Dallas suburb that had a mix of white, Hispanics, and Asians.

When we married he sold his home and moved into mine. He loves gardening and sees yard work as part of his domain. It was then that I noticed a funny thing happening. While he mowed or watered the grass, weeded the flowerbeds, or spread fertilizer, he often engaged in conversation with other men working in their yards. And sometimes one or another of these men would come over and talk to him; sometimes my husband would go over and talk to them about the latest weed-killer or infestation of garden pests.

He learned more about our neighbors in a few months than I had in the years that I lived there. Still, there was no social interaction between us; no invitations to their homes, no invitations to cookouts or Super Bowl parties. One really hot August afternoon, our house caught on fire. My brother and his wife were visiting, and all four of us stood on the driveway as the firemen succumbed to the heat as they battled the fire in the attic. Neighbors came out of their homes, but stayed in their own yards, watching until the summer heat was more than they could stand. Then, silently, they retreated into their air-conditioned enclaves, leaving us standing alone and homeless. After the firemen had been there about an hour, a woman who lived across the street and several houses down came over, carrying a large tray of plastic cups filled with ice water for us. In the emotional state I was in, I saw her gift of cold water as a godsend. She asked if we needed a place to spend the night, and offered her home. We were well insured and the insurance company was very responsive, so we declined and went to a hotel instead. In the days that followed, as we went back to the house to survey the damage and rescue some clothes for our immediate use, we learned that she had organized her friends into donating cleaning supplies, gift certificates for restaurants, movies, and department stores. The damage to the house was extensive enough to warrant our moving out while the repairs were done, but some neighbors offered to water our lawn for us, pick up our mail, and even let us hook up to their outside electrical outlets to install fans while the cleanup crew came in to move our belongings into storage.I wrote each neighbor that helped a heart-felt thank you note.

Once the repairs were done we moved back into the house and life went on pretty much as it had before-the men talked while they did yard work, people waved as we drove by, said hello on the side walk. Although the outward signs stayed the same, I felt a greater connection to my neighbors because I had learned that-when it mattered-they reached out to help.

Learn more about this author, Estela Dela Fuente.
Contact this writer Click here to send Author comments or questions.

No

I really don't know what I would do in such a situation, but must reluctantly vote no to this question. There's still a lot of hate and bigotry on both sides of the color line in America, and even today when I ... a very senior white man ... ride the New York City subway system, I've been involved in incidents, while not quite violent, that clearly expose the continuing tensions.

I've been pushed, cursed and ridiculed by groups of black high school kids. Call it the exuberance of youth, joshing around and showing off, but if it is a clear example of racism, it is as ugly as any similar neighborhood or schoolyard incident. I can certainly sympathize with an elderly black man who may find himself in the same situation. Maybe most of the dreams Martin Luther King wished for 40 years ago have come true, but racism still rears its ugly head too often to ignore it. I can do the politically correct statement here and say I had many close friends during my Navy days and throughout my working career. Although it is absolutely true, it still sounds lame in the light of prejudices in all of us that too often lie just beneath the surface of our consciousness.

We still see too many tragic examples of bigotry in communities throughout the land, particularly where one race dominates in numbers. If I were a young parent today, even though I pride myself in being liberal politically, I'd have to do some realistic thinking before I'd subject my little kids to living as the only white (or black) ones in school and neighborhood situations that could result in intimidation at best, or violence at worst.

When children are born, they are totally dependent on the protection of their parents. No matter what my social and political attitudes, the safety of my child is my absolute priority. If I want to experiment with living with those of different ethnicity, that can be an admirable decision, but I would do it only so long as it affects only me.

Learn more about this author, Ted Sherman.
Contact this writer Click here to send Author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | User Guide | Community | Link to Helium | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA