Home > Politics, News & Issues > News > People in the News
Should Michael Vick have received a stronger sentence?
Title endorsed in part by:
Results so far:
| Yes | 66% | 169 votes | Total: 257 votes | |
| No | 34% | 88 votes |
Yes
by Rhyman Gaines
Created on: March 05, 2009
Dogfighting is illegal. Laws are implemented for the protection of society at large and to reinforce, by legal means, the social and moral ethics we as a society adhere to. On the issue of cruel and inhumane treatment of animals our social conscience demands these acts be punished accordingly.
How do you differentiate between what Michael Vick did and the legally sanctioned testing of chemicals and other substances on animals for scientific advancement, as one being more acceptable than the other? For some people there is little to no difference. Aside from the obvious brutality of Michael Vick's crime there lies the issue of intent. His intent was to break the law and commit repeated acts of cruelty against animals for profit. Eye witness accounts by those that participated in Michael Vick's dogfighting activities have stated under oath that Vick brutalized and killed these dogs by his own hand.
Vick, at one time, was the face of an NFL franchise. His jersey had been a number one seller and many youths and some not so young idolized him for his athletic prowess and professional sports stature. In the harsh light of what he has done he neither deserved nor warranted such adulation. To rationalize that some areas of our country find dogfighting to be an acceptable practice is to say our social and moral conscience should not extend beyond the human condition. To believe that we have only to abandon our sense of compassion.
As to the question should Michael Vick have received a stronger sentence it is my opinion, based on the intentional barbarity of his actions, he has not received sentence enough. What is needed here is a lifetime ban from professional football. Vick will soon walk out of prison and most assuredly attempt to revive his NFL career. It would not be surprising to see him greeting the hordes of awaiting media with a bible in one hand, as he professes to have found salvation, laced with promises that he is a changed man. A good PR machine would have him doing a mini tour of select grade schools where he could sit in front children and explain to them how wrong it is to mistreat animals. A really nice touch would be to have him holding and petting a cute little puppy as he delivers his message.
Based on athletic talent alone the NFL will probably welcome him back. The business side of sport, for the sake of revenue, is all to willing to place greed above better judgement and social ethics. Time will lessen the memory of Vicks crimes. Some will see them as little more than a speed bump in the road to fame and fortune.
Let Vick seek gainful employment elsewhere. Let him write his memoirs and pocket the big advance publishers will eagerly offer him, not to mention the royalty checks. As for me I don't need to buy the book. I've seen the reality show and as we all know nothing compares to real life or death. I wonder what Pete Rose thinks of all this.
Learn more about this author, Rhyman Gaines.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
by Jonathan Clayton
Created on: June 30, 2008 Last Updated: July 06, 2008
The sentence that Michael Vick recieved was harsher than most famous people recieve for much worse crimes in my opinion. I personally was never a Michael Vick fan anyway, because I thought he was extremely arrogrant to be nothing more than a football player, but be that as it may, he got his day in court!
What Mr. Vick did in the deaths of these animals was horrendous, to say the least. But he wasn't endangering someone elses life by driving like a madman while under the influence.Or doing cocaine, like there was no tomorrow.Or engaging in a million, different, unlawful things we see the rich and famous people do everday and get away with, or at the very worst, pay a fine and do community service!
What most people don't understand about the Vick saga is this. In the south, dog fighting has been going on for hundreds of years. In the northern part of this country you have GreyHound racing, Horse racing, and several other animal involved sports. We won't even go into what happens to these animal's after they outlive they're usefulness. Thats another story. But in the south, you have dog fighting and cock fights! Both while cruel in the eyes of most, have been around for centuries!
If you have never been to see a cock-fight, it is just as bloody and cruel as a dog-fight! Unfortunately for the chicken, we don't have the same sentimental feelings for them as we do our family pet!
I was raised in the south, and both of these so called sports, happened every weekend! It was nothing new or out of the ordinary. It was common-place! It was only because it was someone that was in the lime-light, that was doing this activity that it was put on the national stage!
Most people in this country knew full well that this kind of thing was going on, and had been for many years, but it was only when it involved a famous football player, someone that was seen as a role model for our children, and a lot of them looked up to or idolized, that it became a HUGE event! And rightly so!
Michael Vick was made an example of. There's no doubt about that. He got what he deserved, but I as well as the rest of the nation have seen a lot worse being done by the rich and famous, with little to no consequences for they're actions! Mr. Vick lost literally millions of dollars, and most of his career due to his bad judgement. I would say that was punishment enough for his transgressions!
In closing, I can only hope that the next celebrity who breaks the law, pays the same kind of price he did. Real Jail Time!
Learn more about this author, Jonathan Clayton.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills
Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all
INFORMATION
Copyright © 2002-2012 Helium, Inc. All rights reserved.
Helium.com: A Service of RR Donnelley