Home > Health & Fitness > Mental Health > Mental Health (Other)
Results so far:
| No | 42% | 950 votes | Total: 2289 votes | |
| Yes | 58% | 1339 votes |
No
Created on: February 11, 2009 Last Updated: March 29, 2009
Suicide is not a personal right. First, it is a desperate cry for help. A person who is suicidal is a deeply depressed. They feel such pain that living every day is a battle. People who are deeply depressed feel utterly hopeless. They may think they know the reason why they are so miserable, but often times, they have no idea why they feel so horrible. Deep depression is often described as a feeling of such sadness it's unbearable. So, unbearable that once the person begins to "plan" their suicide, they feel happy. The joyful feeling comes from knowing that pain they live with everyday will be over soon.
Also, depression is a complicated disease. Often times depressed people have additional diseases that intensify depression. For instance, they may be an alcoholic. They might suffer from an anxiety disorder. Usually a person who reaches this state of depression has at least one other mental illness. Of course, having another disorder just intensifies the depression.
Then, we still have the mental illness stigma. That we all help promote. Then, the insurance companies don't have to give much coverage for mental illness. A lot of insurance companies believe the brain is not like the heart or lungs. But, in fact, the brain is one of the most important organs in the body. The brain controls everything in the body. So, every one needs to stop judging mental illness as a person's choice. Does a person choose to have diabetes? Mental illness needs to be thought of in the same way.
Since a suicidal person is in such pain. They don't think of others. People who aren't suicidal do think of other people. Severely depressed individuals are focused on themselves. But, some tend to believe that the world would be better off with out them. Others can't tolerate the pain day in and day out.
I believe, it is our responsibility to raise awareness and end the ridiculous stigma of mental illness. More importantly, it is our duty, if we know some one who is threatening suicide to help find them treatment. So, no suicide is not a personal right. Instead, it is our duty to help these people. If some one threatens suicide, they should be taken to an emergency room immediately.
Furthermore, by law, if a person is a danger to himself or a danger to others ,the person should be reported to the police, so they can receive the proper care.
Lastly, in the Bible, suicide is a sin. So, God gives no one the right to take their own life.
Learn more about this author, Trish Austin.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
Yes
Created on: October 22, 2011 Last Updated: October 23, 2011
Your father is dying of old age. He does not know your name. He may have signed the closest thing we have to suicide of the body and that is the 'Health Care Proxy' in modern medicine. He is a DNR.
This means "Do Not Resuscitate." To our society this is okay. He is old and he has no use to our society. As a matter of fact, he is a financial burden to family and the country. So why not let him die in this case?
Now go back a few years, when he was working, or as a active father. He knew your name. He participated in your life. The life insurance company would have insured him for very little money. Life was good and yes, suicide was not part of it.
Now he is ill. He has a incurable painful disease, or an invisible mental illness has stricken him. He can't see a value in his life. Medicine doesn't help and he is suffering in a world that the living says will get better. He knows or feels, that it will not. Now he is expected to live because of the family which he might have forgotten in his old age anyway. Maybe because of the grandchildren which he won't see grow up.
Worse you are now the one caretaker of your children. You try to do your best and agencies keep coming in to tell you that you failed. You become more depressed and your symptoms are not relieved by the medications, from the help you did seek. You turn to God and now you beg his forgiveness. You feel that you are not serving as well as society is saying that you should.
Maybe you a person addicted to drugs. Yes, they say you are a disgrace to your family and another financial burden to society. Maybe you even have a jail record that prevents you from reestablishing your good name.
There are some little reasons that may make one feel that there is no way out. Who says that one must live for others? If a person is in the mist of demons voices, or feels the banishment of God or feels like every person they come in contact with will die, because of their knowing them, what is one to do?
They call them delusions, signs of severe depression and voices from where? Life can be very frightening to live each day. And yes, you are not old enough or sick enough to declare a "DNR" in today's society. A doctor went to jail for his assisted suicides and that may had been 'just.'
I know that the act of suicide is one of the most painful decisions one may ever make. One has to deal with the "what if." They have to deal with the consequences of whom they leave behind prematurely. They have to deal with God, as so many people say suicide is forbidden in the Bible. Maybe... but for me ignorance is bliss. God says,"he gives us what we can handle" but then why are so many people unable to handle their pains.
I know I would be devastated if any of my children committed suicide, as I would feel I had failed them. I also would have to review what I did to help. Was I there for them? Maybe if I committed suicide, I would not had been there for them. Does this necessarily make my suicide their reason to die. No!
Children grow up all the time in divorced families, foster care and in whole homes. It is not necessarily the reason for more suicides. If society would look at the life the person was living before they criticize; then maybe suicides could be as an accepted as "DNR" is. The family could be there and know that all was done to relieve the pain. It wouldn't have to be misunderstood or someone to blame. It wouldn't have to be a shock by a knock on the door. If suicide is taking seriously by everyone and not ridiculed by friends and family; then there might not be a need to commit suicide.
People who commit suicide are in great distress and it is not a easy way to go. It is lonely and frightening. It has it's uncertainties. It is not a decision to make alone but it is necessary in today's society. Suicide prevention centers are not enough. When people are allowed to end their life, despite others opinions as to their pain; there would be at least less suicides which are done without family. There may be less suicide all together, as people will pre-plan and attempt to understand. Also, all possible help will be given.
It is a lonely world, when you are in the mist of ending your life. It is not a selfish act but a desperate act to seek relief. To have to do it alone is the same as murder to me.
Learn more about this author, lily frost.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.