Search Helium

Home > Parenting & Pregnancy > Babies > Feeding & Breastfeeding

Which comes first: Finger foods or spoon?

Results so far:

Fingers
76% 195 votes Total: 255 votes
Spoon
24% 60 votes

Fingers

by Bethany Harvey

Created on: September 30, 2009   Last Updated: October 01, 2009

Ahhh, the joys of feeding your baby. The first decisions of when, what and how are so important. Should you breastfeed or bottle? That is a decision you make long before your baby is born and is very personal. How you first feed your baby is up to you. For many, however, the bottle or breast is not decided by mom or dad but by the baby itself. I am really talking about my own babies. All three were going to be breast fed. All three let me know that they wanted nothing to do with that and just bring on the bottle, please. Of course, it was not so polite as that, and I learned with many tears.

Then the next question is when to introduce solid foods. First, you start out with soft, pureed, liquid foods and cereals. You discover any allergies in the process and what your baby likes to eat. Soon your baby is eating three times or more a day and is taking great interest in what you are eating. Babies are so curious. It is only natural that they find your food a delight. After your baby gets a couple of teeth and can chew or gum their food, the next step looms on the horizon. Should you let your baby eat finger foods or feed themselves with a spoon? This is a personal decision, of course. Some moms are very proper and want their baby to learn correct table manners right from the start. That is ok, but I believe that the next step in your baby's development is finger foods.

Your baby, in the beginning of self-feeding, doesn't have the fine motor skills to hold a spoon in his little hands. It takes a lot of skill to get that spoon to a mouth when it is full of food. A young baby doesn't have the dexterity to do that. If you push your baby too early, you are setting them up for failure and rebellion. Yes, even at this age a baby can rebel. You want to encourage your babies to feed themselves, yes. But giving them a task that they cannot do too early is going to be a step backward for all of you.

As your babies grow, they want to be independent. Encourage this by letting your babies try to feed themselves with small pieces of banana or cooked carrots. Soft cut-up food is a great start. Partially cooked apple pieces that are soft are great. Green beans or other soft-cooked veggies are great, too. Bake a potato and let it cool enough to handle and give pieces of that to your baby. Basically, anything that they can eat is ok. Small pieces of bread or a roll broken up for them or even toast to chew. Look around at what you are eating and share with them. As long as it is soft enough for you baby not to choke, it is ok to give them.

Put your child in a highchair to eat. If you haven't gotten one, now is the time. A highchair is the safest place for a baby to start eating on their own. Strap your baby in, and put a bib on them to protect their clothes. Let them do things their way and just stay close to monitor them. Let them mush, mash and feel their food. It will make it's way to their mouth. Keep wet cleaning clothes nearby and watch your baby learn.

Learn more about this author, Bethany Harvey.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

Spoon

by Freyda Tartak

Created on: September 27, 2009

Long before a baby has enough coordination to grab a piece of food and stuff it in their mouth they have already developed the ability to swallow. Why fight nature? Following a baby's cues is the easiest way for a parent to transition from one stage to the next.

Although some experts warn against giving a baby anything other than breast or bottle, giving a few drops of water from a spoon is a great way to get rid of hiccups and even address colic. Then, when the baby is between four and six months even doctors are starting to recommend adding a bit of cereal to their diet. Clearly, this is done by spoon.

Babies grow so rapidly that it isn't all that long between spoon and finger, in either direction anyway. Offering a Cheerio off the palm of your hand and carefully watching what the baby does with it is good indication of their readiness for finger foods. But, offering a spoon has very little to do with what the baby is able to do with their hands and much more to do with getting them fed and moving on with the rest of the day.

There is enough for a new parent to stay busy with aside from spending countless hours watching a baby attempt to feed themselves. Giving them the autonomy to self feed should can only be done under close watch. This means that you aren't able to do anything else. On the other hand, slowly introducing finger foods once the baby is mostly fed will allow that portion of time to shrink to something much more manageable.

Eventually, all babies want to do it by themselves. You'll be wishing they would just let you spoon feed them so that you can make it to the play date on time. Those will be exciting times but, oh so frustrating. Why rush the process? A baby will always be a lot slower and messier at doing the same things that will take the parent a fraction of the time. Eventually, this is unavoidable and a necessary stage in their physical and cognitive development. But, let them take the initiative and drive the speed with which you get there. It will make life easier for everybody.

Introducing the spoon before the finger will also make it easier to introduce the idea of table manners. Even though they all go through the messy, food everywhere, don't help me stage, it has already been instilled in their brains that eventually they will be expected to rejoin the herd and eat like everybody else. When they become more coordinated and better able to reason it will be much easier to explain to to them the benefits of the spoon as opposed to the spaghetti on the ceiling and the floor.

Learn more about this author, Freyda Tartak.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA