Search Helium

Home > Society & Lifestyle > Morals, Values & Norms > Social Values & Norms

Are overweight people gluttons?

Results so far:

Yes
29% 248 votes Total: 854 votes
No
71% 606 votes

Yes

by Stacia Elizabeth Whitbeck

Created on: April 05, 2008

I've always been fat. People have called me big-boned, thick and sturdy. Family members tell me that I come from big stock and doctors tell me I have good muscle tone. No matter which way you say it, it boils down to fat and you can't become fat unless you are gluttonous.

No matter how big your bones may be, they cannot make you fat. Coming from big stock doesn't make it okay to lug around an extra body part or two, be it an innocent chin or an entire stomach. Coming from big stock is something you might hear at a dairy auction where you can get a couple of nanny goats and a heifer at half price.

My bones are big, I am six feet tall and I am really strong. But, I am also fat and it's because I eat more calories than my body needs. It's not a secret, complex or deep seeded. It's basic. If you eat too much, you could get fat.

The human body was designed to work. Not in a cubicle or at a desk, but real work. The human body was not designed to consume white flour, refined sugar, preservatives, additives, hormones or any of the other chemicals and toxins we consume.

Of course people are going to get sick and fat. I'm not a doctor or a scientist, to the relief of those who know me, but I have never seen an overweight person in a third world country due to a thyroid disorder. I cannot imagine a tribe of people all but emaciated except for Uncle Oogly who can't leave the tent because he weighs five hundred pounds due to a thyroid gone amuck.

Life is hard and sometimes sad. There are no guarantees or rulebooks. People die, dreams fade and things go wrong. Is that really a reason to become gluttonous with substance, sex, work, or food?

Obesity is a convoluted luxury. What about the people who have suffered horribly that don't have the resources to become fat? It makes it seem like Americans shouldn't have the right or the means to become fat.

Life has exceptions but being obese these days is not the exception. People are fat because they can be. There is too much food available in mass quantities. Machines have made most manual labor obsolete.

So why am I still fat? Because I have the luxury of being lazy and ordering pizza or take out when I don't feel like cooking. I run through the drive thru with the kids on a busy night and I eat too fast. I'm not active enough because sometimes I don't feel like it.

Most overweight people are gluttonous.

Learn more about this author, Stacia Elizabeth Whitbeck.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

by Lucas Dobson

Created on: June 03, 2008

Overweight individuals are commonly depicted by the media and in popular entertainment as lazy and gluttonous at worst, and as victims of heredity at best. But with the obesity rates soaring, to include one third of Americans, is it really possible that a huge part of the population just let their bodies go, or could there be something else at work here? Considering our generally high standards of living and access to health clubs, there are seemingly few justifications for excessive weight gain. If weight gain is preventable, the reasoning goes, then overweight people have chosen to become that way.

In many areas of life, personal responsibility can be overshadowed by unfavorable circumstances. Too often, the necessities of life create some problems while solving others. For instance, our jobs may adversly effect our eating habits. This may be in the form of peer pressure, such as an obligatory luncheon with the co-workers. Then there are the subtle, often manipulative influences such as those presented in advertisements. Or a much needed snack after an unexpectedly long day at lunch. Just as people facing starvation and are usually powerless to fight it, a population with obesity rates reaching epidemic proportions can be seen as similarly disempowered. The fact is, people are getting fatter because there is hardly any other choice.

Pervasive advertising renders us incapable of keeping food off of our minds. Just as erotic imagery can and will trigger a physiological response, so too will images of food result in a desire to eat. The marketers who are plastering giant images of burgers on television screens and on the billboards know something consumers generally do not: that the appetite is conditioned by environmental cues. This is known as the "environmental theory of obesity", and is based upon our well known psychological responses and how these interact with the conditions of modern life.

If we examine our busy workdays, sedentary lifestyles, and bad dieting, we are left with a perfect explanation for the alarming statistics. Instead of stigmatizing overweight people we should be helping them. The healing process begins by correcting our attitudes towards our shared predicament. We must treat the causes, not scoff at the effects. This of course goes against years of cultural conditioning and our shared values which attach a great deal of importance to individual responsibility. Thus, while it may seem natural to blame an overweight person for their own state, it is this very attitude which covers up the causes and solutions of the problem itself.

Our nations health is a mutual responsibility, and we must all share in the solution.




http://arti cles.latimes.com/200 8/jan/14/health/he-w eightloss14

Learn more about this author, Lucas Dobson.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.


CONNECT WITH US

Read
our blog
Helum for writers

Write and get published
Share with other writers
Polish your freelancing skills

Join our active writing community
Helium Content Source for Publishers

Quality articles from proven freelancers
Exclusive rights, fast turnaround
Brand engagement, business blogging -- our writers do it all

Get custom content today!

INFORMATION


Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA