Results so far:
| Yes | 56% | 198 votes | Total: 354 votes | |
| No | 44% | 156 votes |
by robertsloan2
Let's look at the context of the noose for whether it's a hate crime. I'm familiar with the recent case in Louisiana that prompted this question. A particular shade tree was use...read more
by Penny Sky
Of course hanging a noose in a public place is a hate crime! No one would place a noose in a public place, for any other reason than pure hatred! It's no different than burning...read more
The Jena Six controversy - occurring last December in Louisiana, where six black students were charged with attempted murder after beating a white student after nooses were plac...read more
by PC Marks
Hanging a noose from a tree, burning a cross in someone's yard or drawing a swastika are all examples of hate crimes where no one got hurt. Or did they? The sole purpose of ...read more
by patty smithe
I hear we have a new trend here in America. Ever since the infamous Jena 6 case, nooses have started cropping up all over our country. The most recent incident was the hanging o...read more
by Rob Purifoy
In considering the angles that come to mind as to whether or not it's a "crime" specifically I am left with comparisons of what is deemed a crime. While we do have freedom of ex...read more
by Lana Evans
It's sad that we have to enact laws to police poor attitudes, but some people really don't care about how their actions are taken. They aren't concerned with whether their behav...read more
by Kylisha Boyd
As a young teen moving to Virginia from New Jersey, I did not know what to expect. All I knew was that we were moving to the South. As far as we knew, we could be moving to th...read more
by Sammy Stein
Hanging a moose in public is definitely a hate crime - whatever has the moose done to you? Yes, they have got big horns and yes, they are a bit on the daft side and yes, they b...read more
by betty warner
Hanging a noose in public should be considered a hate crime. It is an act that incites violence and rage. This behavior causes political and social unrest. The hanging noose is...read more
This is one of those questions like should a rape victim be blamed for being raped. Only it's just the opposite. People may say it is their right to display such things unde...read more
Having lived in the south for 6 years, hanging a noose is definitely a hate crime, if not a terroristic crime. Just because the civil war was fought years ago, with the south l...read more
A very weak, but nonetheless yes that it can be considered a hate crime. Simple put, a noose is not a decoration in that someone would find it appealing since it represents the ...read more
by Carol Smith
Whether you're white or black, read on without regard to your race and what society has taught you about your identity based upon it. Why? Just use your own personal inward v...read more
by P.J. Burns
The answer to the question, "is this a hate crime," is so obviously yes I am finding myself at a loss of words. The object for all who look at it symbolizes death and there a...read more
The mere fact that this is a debate question is utterly ridiculous! Everyone old enough to make a noose knows what it symbolizes, and knows the hate behind it. This hanging of t...read more
Of course hanging a noose in public should be considered a hate crime! Why is it a hate crime? Because it is intended to cause fear in a specific person or group of people. ...read more
Should the hanging noose in public be considered a hate crime? The hanging noose should be considered a hate crime if it is deliberately used to intimidate,harass and malign an ...read more
by Valarie Topp
Yes, Yes, Yes, Yes..............hanging a noose in public should be considered a hate crime. What else is it, that would make you do such a thing. In my opinion, A person that ...read more
A hanging noose is a "slap in the face" for, not only African Americans, but for all of those who have fought for justice in this country that are ...read more
by Dan Weaver
Currently, it is not a crime in New York State to display a hangmans noose, but proposed legislation, already passed in the Senate, seeks to make it one; and similar legislation...read more
by Ann Caimen
Personally, I think the term 'hate crime' is wrong, stupid, and overused. Most crimes are done in a 'hateful' manner, yet the ones that involve race are usually the ones that ar...read more
by Duane Kuehn
Some people seem to love an environment of hatreds. They just cannot stop finding new ways to express how hatful others are. Sometimes such things as a hanging noose, i...read more
First of all, lets define a hate crime. A hate crime is generally defined as a violent crime against someone due to race, gender, or sexual orientation. Hating someone in genera...read more
Should hanging a noose in public be considered a hate crime? The Noose: A length of rope with the end fashioned into a noose used for the purpose of hanging. Hanging a pe...read more
by Jimmy Ettele
In this country we allow for freedom of speech. Freedom to express our ideas, concepts, and points of view no matter how putrid their meaning is. While I believe we all felt t...read more
by Rex Coker
"It is symbolism in bad taste" . The rope did not jump out and commit a crime , it is just the symbol of of a dying age , just like the Confederate flag . Is it a hate crime for...read more
I understand where the noose has gotten its reputation and I understand that it has been used for some very bad things. I also understand that we are living in a very uptight s...read more
Should hanging a noose in public be considered a hate crime? First of all I have to say before I go any further that I am not some uneducated, hate-monger, white-power perso...read more
by Nancy Lynam
This subject of whether or not hanging a noose in public is a hate crime strikes me as just another subject to "give some sensationalism" to the news media in any form. My imme...read more
by Chabu Bowler
In this day and age when anything and everything could be considered a "hate crime", it is important to recognize the spirit in which something is done. Hanging a noose, in its...read more
The mere fact that this is a debatable question in today's society saddens and disgusts me. Hanging a noose in public view as an expression of bigotry and discrimination is a te...read more
Should hanging a noose in public be considered a hate crime? A better question is why should it be? Hanging was and still is used around the world. As a matter of fact sever...read more
by Taylor Novia
While I certainly do not condone the implications of the noose hanging in public, I do not think it should be considered a hate crime. A Crime is but is not limited to a physica...read more
by Larry Head
Absolutely Not, unless we are going to outlaw flag burning as well. The answer to this will most likely be determined in either a state Supreme Court or the US Supreme Court. ...read more
People who are defeated by the image assOCIATED with hate, will never stand a chance at actually overcoming that ideology. Grab a pair and stand up in the face of adversity. Mos...read more
by Joe Nienaber
So called hate crimes are an unequal form of punishment and are strictly banned by the Constitution. The only reason we have them is to set a precedent for unequal punishment fo...read more
by Sean Davis
with people of every color being hung and having been hung, how and why did it become a hate crime? I know that there will always be a difference of opinion on the question b...read more
by Samantha V.
If we consider hanging a noose in public to be a hate crime, then we're going to have to get a lot more specific as to the terms and what constitutes a noose hanging in public a...read more
Hanging a noose in public should not, a priori, constitute a hate crime. It depends on the circumstances and the locale. A noose in my front yard on Halloween as part of a speci...read more

