No

• 1 of 8

  by John Rodrigue

  Created on: February 05, 2008

  Neither one of these authors understands what they are talking about.
  
  Anyone, citizen, legal or illegal

• 2 of 8

  by Michael Isaacson

  Created on: October 26, 2007

  If being here unlawfully, and I assume the question refers to illegal immigrants, is a crime, then it

• 3 of 8

  by Arthur Gibson

  Created on: January 25, 2008

  No, it's not un-American, particularly if you are talking about illegal aliens. Anyone entering this

• 4 of 8

  by Carrington M. Nye

  Created on: February 26, 2008

  My head is literally spinning: Was I asked if it were Un-American that detained immigrants [in other

• 5 of 8

  by Donna Marie Gray

  Created on: October 24, 2007

  If a person is in this country illegally, how can it be un-American for them to be denied an attorney

• 6 of 8

  by Joe Polo

  Created on: October 25, 2007

  It's interesting that the Debate title simply calls them immigrants.
  If they were here legally - the

• 7 of 8

  by Danette M. Scott

  Created on: October 25, 2007

  It is unfair and UN-American that 84% of all detained immigrants have no lawyer or access to a fair

• 8 of 8

  by Hugh Arthur

  Created on: October 25, 2007   Last Updated: November 04, 2008

  This is a poorly crafted question, as the potential variables involved define the answer. Are the immigrants