Join | Log in

Channel Button
Debate_icon

Politics, News & Issues   >

US Immigration

Get a Widget for this title

Should driver's licenses be issued to illegal immigrants?

Results so far:

Yes
27% 160 votes Total: 595 votes
No
73% 435 votes
Yes

Should illegal aliens be permitted to get an American driver's license?

Most American states refuse to provide driver's licenses to illegal aliens. As a result, an estimated 8 to 20 million drivers in the US have no license and no insurance. Additionally, local police have few methods of tracking down illegal aliens when they are suspects for crimes. The net result is this dysfunctional policy causes America to be more dangerous and it also causes auto insurance rates to be higher than necessary.

Granted that American immigration policy is broken and our borders are effectively open to the world. Both need to be fixed. The INS needs to track down those who overstay their visas. The borders need to be buttoned up with fences and surveillance by satellites and other electronic means as well as beefed up staffing. It is self-evident that we need a guest worker program that requires document registration, but without a pathway to US citizenship. This would allow the law to reflect reality.

Eventually, there will be some type of accommodation with the problem of illegal aliens. In the meantime, why should we penalize all Americans, while we wait for our politicians to figure out the solution? Being illegally in the US does not mean that foreigners are not here or that they do not drive here. The problem of illegal immigration is an old one and the history is that periodically, America has given amnesties to the illegals and enabled them to become citizens. Whether or not that happens again can be separated from the subject of whether or not to issue driver's licenses to undocumented aliens.

Of course, making illegals eligible for driver's licenses does not guarantee that they would obtain them. However, as long as they are ineligible, you can be assured that they will not have valid driver's licenses. If the objective is to try to ensure that every active driver has a valid driver's license for road safety purposes, then everything possible should be done to enable all drivers to be able to have a license.

When there are millions of drivers who have not taken a driver's license test, there are millions of drivers on the road who probably do not know the traffic safety laws.
That likely translates into thousands and thousands of additional accidents, many of the hit and run variety, since if they stop, the police will ask for I.D. and the foreigner could be at risk of deportation.

New York Governor Spitzer has announced plans to allow illegal aliens to apply for driver's licenses there. It has fostered a storm of protest by Lou Dobbs of CNN. However, illegal aliens can get a driver's license in Kentucky, Hawaii, Illinois, Michigan, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Carolina, North Dakota, Oregon, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Utah, Vermont, Washington and Wisconsin. In California, Gov. Schwarzenegger is discussing legislation that would allow illegals to get their licenses. Over a third of the America's 50 states have already decided to allow driver's licenses to be issued to foreigners.

Learn more about this author, Robert C. Sage.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

No

There is no doubt that illegal immigration is a huge and complex problem in the United States, largely due to the ineptness and inaction of our political leaders. Instead of taking measures to solve the problem and reduce the back breaking strain on public resources that illegal immigration is having on our society, our politicians instead debate ways to make life easier and grant more rights to illegal immigrants. The hypocrisy of their actions is astounding on many levels.

Millions of illegal immigrants live in our country today, using our tax payer funded resources every day while giving little to nothing back to the system. Most illegal immigrants work "under the table" due to their illegal status in the country, as a result pay no income tax. They live in crowded apartments with groups of other illegals because of justifiable restrictions on housing thus reducing the property taxes they pay and further reducing their contribution to society. Yet every day they use our hospital emergency rooms like their own personal physicians, claiming charity care in a broken health care system that is seeing more and more hospitals close or declare bankruptcy every day.

A massive burden is placed on police and fire, EMS and local governments who are dealing with the massive influx of illegal immigrants who do little to nothing to support the system they are thriving on. Their children flood into our schools increasing class sizes, reducing the overall education quality to taxpaying citizen's children and increasing the costs of education for those who are paying their fair share of taxes. All the while the meager funds they earn working illegally in the United States are funneled back to their homes in other countries robbing the United States of the economic fluidity that a working economy needs to survive.

Yet instead of supporting some of the grass roots efforts already underway to alleviate the burden placed on society by illegal immigrants our politicians seem intent on going out of their way to better the lives of illegal immigrants. It is no secret what the political motivation is for this misguided effort. The country is rapidly leaning towards a mass naturalization of its illegal immigration population. As we continue to allow the problem to get worse without doing anything constructive to curb the tide of illegal immigration the country is quickly becoming frustrated with the situation. The politicians are counting on this frustration leading to one single and unified shrug of the American shoulders as we concede the only solution is to naturalize the estimated twenty five million illegal immigrants currently in the country. When this happens the greedy politicians are counting on a new massive block of votes that they will be able to turn in their favor. Clearly the best interests of the country are not in the forefront of our representatives intentions.

In our hyper-paranoid super security conscious near police state where our government wants us to believe there is a terrorist lurking around every corner reminiscent of the "red scare" of the 1950's, even the thought of giving illegal immigrants drivers licenses seems counter-intuitive. We use our driver's licenses for everything from applying for credit cards to boarding airplanes. It has become the ubiquitous form of identification; it is trusted and accepted by just about everyone. In the wake of the "drivers license for sale" controversy that gripped the state of New Jersey only a few short years ago that resulted in the famed and some would say infamous digital drivers license, one would think we would be far more cautious regarding who we issue drivers licenses to. This is especially the case when considering issuing a drivers license to someone who you can't even confirm their home address or real name.

It would be nave to think that illegal immigrants aren't driving now even without drivers licenses. So the question begs to be asked, why issue drivers licenses? What benefit is there to society? If illegal immigrants, who by the very nature of their title and presence in this country indicate they have little to no reservation about breaking the law in the first place are already driving illegally, why would they bother to apply for a drivers license? Even if they were issued drivers licenses, do we honestly expect them to acquire the prerequisite car insurance so they can drive legally? The whole concept of issuing someone the privilege and it is a privilege not a right, a driver's license that is in the country under false pretenses is quite simply illogical. What comes after driver's licenses, library cards, voter registration cards, gun permits? Where do you draw the line?

Learn more about this author, Joseph Whalen.
Contact this writer Click here to send this author comments or questions.

What is Helium? | Buy Web Content | Contact Us | Privacy | User agreement | DMCA | User Tools | Help | Community | Helium’s Official Blog | Link to Helium

Helium, Inc.
200 Brickstone Square Andover, MA 01810 USA