Home > Politics, News & Issues > US Law & Justice > Justice System
Results so far:
| Yes | 62% | 361 votes | Total: 581 votes | |
| No | 38% | 220 votes |
Yes
Created on: October 25, 2009 Last Updated: October 29, 2009
Smoking around your children should be abuse. If you smoke in your home, you are creating a harmful environment for your kids. I am 15 years old and my mom has been smoking since I was 11 years old. I have to take allergy medication three times a day because my house is full of smoke. I have problems breathing and speaking.
I believe children shouldn't have to suffer the way I have the past 4 years. They are our future and we cannot risk them being harmed. I am moving out in a week because my doctor told me, " You have to move out of your home. If you don't leave you could die." Right away I knew I must move out and go to my father in San Diego.
I will not be able to ever see my mother face-to-face unless she stops smoking. I always ask her, "Why is it so relaxing and calming? How could you like the environment you have created?" She told me how she is an adult and I should worry about myself. I don't think she realizes, if she dies of lung cancer, I will not be sorry. I will know that she didn't listen to me.
By ignoring me, she has to face the consequences of death and being without the ones who love her. My father agreed with me when I told him I could not be around her if this is what she does. At my 12th birthday party, my mother, smoked the whole time on our front porch while the party was in the backyard. She didn't see me and my family. My friends. Her friends. They all asked, " Where is Annette?" My father was so devastated to say, "Annette is on the front porch, smoking. She went there with 3 packs and hasn't come back since the whole party began."
At the end of the party, my mom hadn't left the porch, but her friends and mine as well, had left the party. The cake was gone. Eaten. My presents were torn open and revealed. My mother had missed a memory, out of the thousands that have already happened. My family members offered to watch over me and become my guardian, but my father thought my mother would be able to quit. I have had to face the challenges of seeing my mother after that day. It wasn't easy and will never be.
Learn more about this author, Hannah Schwartz.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.
No
Created on: September 12, 2009 Last Updated: September 13, 2009
Smoking is a terrible, filthy habit, yet I've been a smoker since I was about 13 years old. Growing up, it seemed as though everyone smoked. In restaurants, malls, the car, and at home. Then, suddenly everything changed. Now people are saying it is child abuse, yet I don't remember feeling abused by my mother's constant lighting up. I must say, I had a pretty good childhood, despite all of the evil smokers around.
When I became pregnant with my first daughter, I smoked throughout. People constantly felt it was their duty to tell me all the damage I was causing to my unborn baby, and treated me like I must not love her or care because I smoked. Of course, my doctor told me I should quit, but even he wasn't mean and judgemental like the strangers I encountered.
My daughter was born healthy and perfect, and frankly there was no difference in the nursery between her and the other non-smoker's babies. I tried to smoke outside at home, and was successful for the first 9 months. But when she started to move around more, it became safer to smoke around her than to leave her unattended, even for a moment.
One thing I noticed out of all of this was how people reacted. It really is funny how a child can be covered in bruises and nobody says a word, but light up in front of your child and you become the devil. I've actually been in a restaurant with my daughter eating, and had people come in and sit right next to us, light a smoke, and then complain about me having my child around it. It's ridiculous.
So, we all know that smoking is bad for you, and second hand smoke is also bad. But is it any worse than sitting in traffic while car exhaust flows freely all around? Or living in a city that is full of smog? Or sitting next to a campfire? Sure it affects their lungs, but so do many things that are considered neither abusive or dangerous. We inhale toxins every day, that is just how the world is now.
To villify a parent for smoking around their kids is merely an excuse for certain people and groups to have a reason to complain. Of course, if you are forcing your child to smoke, then that is probably child abuse. Otherwise, throughout the years almost everyone who has ever smoked would be guilty of child abuse at some point. Remember, it used to be legal to smoke almost everywhere.
I am sure at some point we all as parents have done something that could damage our children. I know my children are happy, and healthy therefore they are not being abused. Being a smoker does not make you a child abuser, nor does it make you a bad parent.
I have never seen a child in counselling because their parents smoked, and to be totally honest, there isn't nearly enough being done about real abuse to start considering smoking to be child abuse.
Learn more about this author, Chola Mccabe.
Click here to send this author comments or questions.